Plant hero background

Find the top real estate agents in Menai

As Australia's #1 real estate agent comparison site, we help over 2.6 million Australians research agents every year.*

Compare real estate agents
Compare real estate agents
Loading...

Some of the top local agents in Menai

These agents are strong performers in the local area.

Find out more about Menai property prices, market trends and demographics.

Local
Oliver Powell

Oliver Powell

KORE Shire Partners - Menai

28

Sales (12m)

$3.12M

Highest sale

10y

Experience

Houses sold icon

24 Houses

Sold (12m)

Units sold icon

3 Units

Sold (12m)

Local
Chelsea Sly

Chelsea Sly

Highland - Sutherland Shire & St George

11

Sales (12m)

$1.43M

Highest sale

22y

Experience

Houses sold icon

5 Houses

Sold (12m)

Units sold icon

6 Units

Sold (12m)

Local
James Holt

James Holt

James Holt Residential

14

Sales (12m)

$2.2M

Highest sale

38y

Experience

Houses sold icon

9 Houses

Sold (12m)

Units sold icon

3 Units

Sold (12m)

Get more personalised agent results tailored to your property and needs

What makes selling in Menai unique?

Menai sits in Sydney's southern suburbs and offers a mix of established detached houses, townhouses and low-rise apartments in a suburban setting. While Menai appeals to a broad range of buyers, families are an important part of the local market, often drawn to larger gardens, flexible layouts and local services, while smaller dwellings suit those seeking lower-maintenance living or investment opportunities.

Different properties in Menai attract different audiences, so an agent with suburb-specific experience can adjust pricing, presentation and marketing to reflect those distinctions. They understand how to position a property to the buyers most likely to be interested and can tailor a campaign to suit the type of home on offer.

Last Updated: November 2026

Menai property market trends and insights

Over the past year, house prices in Menai have increased 9% to $1.8m, while unit values have increased 4% to $1.2m, suggesting demand has been stronger for detached houses. It also recorded an auction clearance rate of 71%, above the NSW average of 56%.

In Menai, 140 properties have come onto the market over the past year, up 15%, while 138 have sold, an increase of 3%. With both listings and sales higher, homes here are selling in a median of 25 days, 1 day faster than the Sutherland Shire average.

Choosing an experienced local agent who can accurately price your property, market it effectively and negotiate confidently can make a meaningful difference to your sale outcome.

MetricCurrentMarket insight
Median sale price (houses)(2)$1.83M
Up 8.9% YoY
Median sale price (apartments)(2)$1.22M
Up 7.0% YoY
Auction clearance rate (12m)(1)71.3%
Above the NSW average of 55.6%
Listings (12m)138
Up 14.1% YoY
Sales (12m)(2)128
Down 7.2% YoY
Median days on market (12m)(2)25 days
2 days faster than the Sutherland Shire area

Last updated: November 2026, based on OpenAgent & Domain data

See which agents sold the most properties like yours in Menai

Loading...

Why choosing the right local agent in Menai matters

Not all agents deliver the same results. We've analysed local sales data from the past year to show exactly how much the top-performing agents outpace the market average in Menai.

Days on market

The top 3 agents in Menai sell 1.2x faster than the suburb average.

25

Days

Suburb avg.

21

Days

Top 3 agents

Listings sold

The top 3 agents in Menai sell 10% more of their listings than the average in this area.

Suburb avg.
79.7%
Top 3 agents
87.5%

Proportion of total sales

The top 3 agents in Menai are responsible for 30.5% of all property sales in the suburb.

Pie chart: top 3 agents 30.5%, remaining agents 69.5%Remaining agents69.5%Top 3 agents30.5%

What to pay your Menai agent

In New South Wales, real estate agent commission rates typically range from 0.5% to 4.71%. Our data shows the commission rates in Menai average around 1.63%, or approximately $26,817 on a median-priced home.

Real estate commission rates are not regulated, meaning agents can set their own fees. Knowing the average commission in your suburb gives you a useful benchmark when comparing proposals.

Agent commissions are usually negotiable. While commission is an important consideration, it shouldn't be the only factor when choosing an agent. Instead, look for agents with local expertise who can justify their rate and clearly explain how they plan to maximise your sale outcome.

  • Menai avg commission
    1.6%
  • NSW avg commission
    1.9%
  • National avg commission
    2.1%
Loading...

(1) Auction clearance rate data has been sourced from Domain Insight.

(2) Sales, DOM and sale price data for the suburb were sourced from Domain Insight.

Source: Copyright © 2026 Australian Property Monitors Pty Ltd trading as Domain Insight (DI). This information is published and compiled by DI and in developing it DI also relies on the information supplied by a number of external sources.

Data provided by Domain Insight

Customer service centre: 1800 817 616

For more information about our data sources and methodology, please see our Website Data Disclaimers.